|
THE HOUSE WITHOUT A KEY
BEHIND THAT
CURTAIN:
Sir George
Mannering finishes his phone call but puts it on the table instead of back on the cradle.
Eric Durand’s
right arm is up resting on the chain support (of the swing) when Eve Durand says she’s going to the bazaar. His arm is down at his side in the shot when she leaves.
Eve Durand’s
hair is very short when she begs Col. Beetham to take her with him on his four month trek through India and Persia (now Iran). Four months later, at the end of the journey through the desert, her hair is still
short.
BLACK CAMEL:
Shelah Fane and the Hawaiian boy shift positions
depending on the camera position.
Keep an eye on her hair color
as she leaves the beach “set” and goes into her dressing tent. Julie
O’Neill (her secretary) also seems to have hair color changes. [She may
have been wearing a wig. (Courtesy of Rush Glick).
When Shelah’s secretary
pulls up, she parks behind Alan Jaynes, who is waiting for Shelah. A few
minutes later, Shelah leaves her tent and goes out and to the right instead of straight forward to his car. A few minutes later, she is in his car.
When she get out at the hotel
for her Tarnevarro appointment, she tells Jayne to come early that night for her party.
He promised to come “hours early.” So why did she apparently
leave him alone?
When Tarneverro is paged to
meet Charlie, he is visiting with the MacMasters. They refer to him as Jimmy. If his name is Arthur (as we find out later in the movie), then why do they call him
“Jimmy?”
Tarneverro tells Charlie that
he is not in Honolulu for professional reasons, i.e., to read fortunes. Later
in Chan’s car, he admits that Shelah came to him for “advice.”
HOW COME NO ONE IN HONOLULU
(OR IN HOLLYWOOD THREE YEARS BEFORE) NOTICED HOW MUCH TARNEVARRO LOOKED LIKE DANNY MAYO?!
If Alan Jaynes really loves
Shelah Fane, why does he keep trying to get out of town instead of staying and trying to find her killer? (Courtesy of Beckey
Truesdale).
Why can’t Charlie see
Tarneverro or Julie O’Neill picking up the scattered pieces of Danny Mayo’s torn picture.
On the second day, Charlie
talks to the MacMasters about having talked to them that morning. Possibly such
a scene was made and either deleted or never added.
Was the actress playing Charlie’s
oldest daughter at the breakfast table the same one who played Lee’s girlfriend on the telephone in Shanghai, Ivy Ling
(aka Bo Ling) in Calling Philo Vance (with James Stevenson as Vance)?
Yes.
What do Black Camel, Monte Carlo,
Honolulu,
Shadows Over Chinatown, and Shanghai Chest have in common?
Meals at table.
CHARLIE CHAN’S
CHANCE:
What do Chance, Egypt
and Murder Over New York have in common?
They all use glass
containers filled with gas.
What do Charlie Chan’s Chance,
Shanghai, Secret, Treasure Island, Murder Cruise, and Castle
in the Desert have in common?
They
all have cats in them.
What do Chance, Broadway, Panama, and Sky Dragon have
in common
Chance
(Charlie), Broadway (Lee), Panama (Lionel Atwill) and Sky Dragon (Lee and
Birmingham Brown) all broke into ladies’ dressing rooms
in theatres.
CHARLIE CHAN’S GREATEST CASE
ERAN
TRECE (SPANISH VERSION OF CC’S GREATEST CASE):
[This
is not a blooper but a difference between the English and Spanish versions.] There is a segment of a party sequence in the
Spanish version where Minchin and his wife entertain the others
CHARLIE
CHAN’S COURAGE:
What do Chance, Egypt and Murder Over New York have in common?
They all use
glass containers filled with gas.
What do
Charlie Chan’s Chance, Shanghai, Secret, Treasure Island,
Murder Cruise, and Castle in the Desert have in common?
They
all have cats in them.
What do
Chance, Broadway, Panama,
and Sky Dragon have in common
Chance (Charlie), Broadway (Lee), Panama (Lionel Atwill) and Sky
Dragon (Lee and Birmingham Brown) all broke into ladies’
dressing rooms in theatres.
CHARLIE CHAN IN LONDON:
The name of Paul Gray
(played by Douglas Walton) is incorrectly listed in the cast of characters as being “Hugh Gray.”
Pamela Gray’s dress
at the end during the dinner party—doesn’t that “thing” at her neck look like a bat upside down and
hanging from her throat?!
What
do London,
Paris, Circus, and Reno have
in common?
Charlie
tells the investigating officer that if you want a wild bird to sing, do not put him in cage.
CHARLIE CHAN IN PARIS:
Why do Max Corday and Henri
Latouche share the beggar’s costume, thinking that no one can tell their voices apart?
Charlie drinks champagne in Paris but doesn’t
in Shanghai or Race Track.
How can Victor promise to
get Charlie an appointment at ten o’clock the very next morning?
Yvette Larmartine’s hood changes places as
they enter Le Sangh Bleu.
How can anyone reach a gun around a door and shoot
it without using the sight?
At the end, how did Charlie get his flashlight
tied to the broomstick so quickly?
What do
Paris, Treasure Island and Murder Cruise have in common?
They have at
least two different actors using the same costume and no one can apparently tell them apart by their voices.
What do
Paris, Shanghai, Treasure Island
and Murder Cruise have in common?
They all have
beggars in them.
What do
London, Paris, Circus, and Reno
have in common?
Charlie tells
the investigating officer that if you want a wild bird to sing, do not put him in cage.
What do
Paris and Shanghai have in
common?
The supposed
bad guy in both is given away by their thumbprint with a scar shows up on the “smoking gun”.
CHARLIE CHAN IN EGYPT:
The two aerial shots approaching the Sphinx look
like two different camera angles.
The hat that Snow shoes stops
is dusty and the crown is bent in. When the Arab hands it back to Charlie, it
is as pristine as when it was blown off Charlie’s head.
They need only 4 men to move the sarcophagus of
Ameti.
The necklace/amulet that is
supposed to be around the neck of Ameti’s mummy is seen through the X-ray to be in front of the body, as though it could
have been added when the body was wrapped.
How many men carried straight razors like Snowshoes
in their pants everyday?
Who
did Rita Cansino later become and after what changes?
She became
Rita Hayworth after her hairline had been raised and widened and her hair color
dyed red.
What do
Chance, Egypt and Murder Over New York
have in common?
They all use
glass containers filled with gas.
CHARLIE CHAN IN SHANGHAI:
What kind of jade the box
is since you can see the stitching. (Courtesy of Rush Glick)
When was the box rigged and by whom?
As Miss Lamartine comes storming
out of the bank, upset because her ex-“boy friend” (Geez, that guy had to be 40 years older than her!) [sic] has saved romantic letters she wants back, kinda blows off Charlie.
As Charlie turns to enter the bank, there is a patron of the bank, there is a patron of the bank ready tro exit the
bank. In the flash of an eye, as Charlie starts to enter the bank, the man disappears!
(Courtesy of Bill Lutters).
. . . the fellow who is a
phoney and comes to pick up Charlie is in a Dark Blue(Navy Blue is almost black) uniform, its may 1st…the
British like us Americans in uniform have winter and summer uniforms, you will note the guy is in a very dark uniform all
the rest of the military people you see on the street and else where are wearing the light colored “summer” uniforms…only
on sailor on the street has a dark uniform on with a flat hat, he looks like a Marine…he is probably from a visiting
ship, who may be passing thru and has not switched over as yet, as some Captains
don’t always do as a base does…I noticed it for a while, but hadn’t said anything, that just may be why
Charlie called what he thought was the Inspector or what ever he was in charge of law inforcement, anyway he was a British
Official, as I believe Shanghai was a British Crown Colony at that time… hope this intrigues you . . . while on the
ship he [Charlie] sings to some children, the back ground of clouds never changes…it’s a painted back ground,
and not a really good one at that, but I love this movie, spies and stuff…. (Courtesy
of Evan Thompson)
Charlie drinks champagne in Paris but doesn’t
in Shanghai or Race Track.
At the ending, James Andrews/Russell
Hicks pushes his hat back in a close up but it doesn’t match the medium shot of him with his hat in the same position
it was in before the close shot.
What is
the irony in Warner Oland signing about Princess Ming Lo Fu?
Oland made
three other pictures as Fu Manchu, who is mentioned in the song.
Was the
actress playing Charlie’s oldest daughter at the breakfast table the same one who played Lee’s girlfriend on the
telephone in Shanghai, Ivy Ling (aka Bo Ling) in Calling Philo Vance (with James Stevenson as Vance)?
Yes.
What do
Charlie Chan’s Chance, Shanghai,
Secret, Treasure Island, Murder Cruise, and Castle in the Desert have in common?
They
all have cats in them.
What do
Paris and Shanghai have in
common?
The supposed
bad guy in both is given away by their thumbprint with a scar shows up on the “smoking gun”.
What do
Paris, Shanghai, Treasure Island
and Murder Cruise have in common?
They all have
beggars in them.
What
do Shanghai, Monte Carlo, Honolulu
and The Feathered Serpent have in common?
Lee’s
artwork: We see his work in Shanghai, he’s exhibiting one of his works
in Paris in Monte Carlo, Lee is in Art School
in Honolulu and he copies a map in free-hand in The Feathered
Serpent.
What
do Shanghai and Shanghai Chest
have in common?
Charlie sings in Shanghai and Tommy (on violin) and Birmingham (at piano) do a Chop Suey Boogie Woogie duet.
CHARLIE
CHAN’S SECRET:
How did
the killer[s] know when and how Allen Colby would be coming home so as to plan to kill him before Colby reached San Francisco?
The bridge
being built in the scene where Charlie is headed for San Francisco by clipper is most likely the Oakland Bay Bridge. (Courtesy
of Rush Glick).
. . .
[A]t the beginning of Charlie Chan’s Secret, there are two divers underwater, but only one is brought up, or did I just
miss the other one? (Courtesy of RANDLESEKTA@aol.com) .
When
the diver brings up Allan Colby’s briefcase, it’s wet. It’s
dry in the close-up, as are the papers that Charlie looks over in the boat’s cabin.
The papers don’t look like they’ve ever even BEEN wet!
How come
Allen Colby didn’t see the panel in the wall open so the murderer could toss the knife and kill him? And how easily could the killer toss the knife through that size of hole in the wall?
When
Dick Williams meets Alice Lowell at Colby house, they end up in the séance room where he changes how he rests his arms on
the back of a chair, depending on the camera shot used.
When
is the short-wave radio set up at Colby House, not to mention the ultraviolet light?
How could anyone know that they/he would be needing the light and in that position and in that place?
How did
Professor Bowen flick the hidden switch to turn on the “ghost music” sent from their apartment for the séance?
How did
Allan Colby’s body get in the hidden passage-way door during the first séance, and hw does he stay popped up, only to
suddenly fall down the stairs?
Does
Charlie bring a chemical analysis bag on each case? If he doesn’t then
how does he know which ones to bring it on? (Courtesy of Beckey Truesdale).
When
Charlie comes back to the Lowell House after discovering the rifle in the church bell tower, he moves the vase to the table
for it to act as target for the rifle. How come there was water waiting in it
for Baxter to put flowers in it?
Watch
the vase after Baxter puts the flowers in it. Freeze the frame when the bullet
hits the vase. (Courtesy of Rush Glick).
Watch
Baxter when the vase is shot up. He is sprayed with water as he turns and jumps
into the Inspector’s arm. When the camera angel shifts, Baxter is completely
dry.
Why wasn’t
the Professor arrested at least for conspiracy to murder or accessory after the fact?
Does Charlie bring a chemical analysis bag to each case? If he doesn’t, how does he know which ones to bring it on?
What mode of transportation do the following have in common:
Secret, Olympics, Reno,
Treasure Island, and Panama?
They all have characters traveling in clippers.
What do Charlie Chan’s Chance, Shanghai, Secret, Treasure
Island, Murder Cruise, and Castle in the Desert have in common?
They all have cats in them – possibly Puzzums!
CHARLIE
CHAN AT THE CIRCUS:
Marie
Norman is listed in her publicity as Marie Normand.
What do London, Paris, Circus, and Reno
have in common?
Charlie tells the investigating officer that if you want a wild bird to sing, do not put him
in cage.
What is so special about the appearance of J. Carroll Naish in CC at the Circus?
He not only appeared in Circus, he was the main bad guy. Naish went on to be the only actor (and bad guy!) to also play the Chinese detective, on English television
in a half-hour drama in the 1950’s.
CHARLIE
CHAN AT THE RACE TRACK:
Charlie
drinks champagne in Paris but doesn’t in Shanghai or Race Track.
What do
Race Track,
Panama and the Chan boys have in common?
Charlie recognizes Lee in Race Track and Jimmy in Panama
as cabin boys from seeing their backsides and all the spankings he gave them growing up.
CHARLIE
CHAN AT THE OPERA:
The newspaper
section that Gravelle tears up at the beginning of the movie has a headline with the number 7 spelled out as seven. The headline has the number 7 written in Arabic (7) later in the Inspector’s office.
When
Lee goes down through the trap door, he faces the stage area like he’s going down a staircase. In the next shot, from the floor below, he’s at a 90-degree angle from his position in the previous
shot and going down a ladder.
What do Opera, Murder Cruise and Feathered Serpent
have in common?
They
all involve weapons that have been wiped clean of fingerprints by someone who may be the bad guy; Opera and Feathered Serpent
used a dagger or knife and Murder Cruise used a gun.
What do
Opera and Olympics have in common?
Lee
picks pockets; cigarette “holders” in Opera and Arthur Hughes’ pocket in Olympics.
CHARLIE
CHAN AT THE OLYMPICS:
Not exactly
a blooper, the masking of the Swastika to obliterate it from the fin of the zeppelin.
Yvonne
Roland’s wardrobe (including the infamous white fox fur) is left behind on the ship.
Does she have—or get—an entirely new one (including new furs) in Berlin?
How did
Miss Roland get down off of that very large ship from her porthole to the boat in the water over 50 feet below in a heavy
fog without being seen by anyone? Now you must realize all ships in dense fog
have extra lookouts all over the ship watching for other ships and dangers in the water, forward and aft and along both port
and starboard sides..and when a ship that large enters into a river or port (especially) river, there is a pilot boat comes
along side to bring it into a bouy or dock, in this case a passenger ship it would go dockside…and a special sea detail
is set and a port of entrance always sends out a local special pilot to bring the ship in, he takes over from the ships captain,
as he know the channels of deep and shallow waters so the ship will not run aground, now saying all that, was she strong enough
to go hand over hand down a small line some 50 or more feet without losing her grip, set down in a small boat while this large
ship is underway? Without being detected by anyone, you see its quite quiet in fog, and a lookout topside would have heard
the engines of a small craft coming alongside, and if he had seen her going over the side he would more than likely shouted
out Man Overboard…its not easy to lower someone into a small boat even tho the large ships wake wouldn’t be too
bad it would still cause problems…of Olympic proportions…pun intended…theres more to it but this will do
for now… (Courtesy of Evan Thompson, expert, having spent 4 years
at sea in the U. S. Navy)
Why does
the German policeman coming over the car radio sound like a Los Angeles policeman straight out of Dragnet.
It just
seems at the end of Olympics…Hughes the guy who wants Lee to stand alone so they will shoot him if Charlie doesn’t
give out the info as to where the invention is, but then the police bust in and he doesn’t get the chance, they nail
the guy with the ink on his feet and the spies…but Hughes seems to get off as no one approaches him to arrest him, then
we jump to Lee swimming…UGH…not the ending I was expecting to a great story other wise…. (Courtesy of Evan Thompson)
What do
Olympics, Monte Carlo and City in Darkness have in common?
They all have
the same set for the climax of the films.
What do
Opera and Olympics have in common?
Lee
picks pockets; cigarette “holders” in Opera and Arthur Hughes’ pocket in Olympics.
What
mode of transportation do the following have in common: Secret, Olympics, Reno, Treasure Island, and Panama?
They all have
characters traveling in clippers.
What do
Olympics and Shadows Over Chinatown have in common?
They both use
sign language.
CHARLIE
CHAN ON BROADWAY:
Why does
Charlie have seasickness all of a sudden when he’s been on ships, boats, planes, and zeppelins except for the possibility
of a plot device.
What do
Chance, Broadway,
Panama, and Sky Dragon have in common?
Chance (Charlie), Broadway (Lee), Panama (Lionel Atwill) and Sky
Dragon (Lee and Birmingham Brown) all broke into ladies’
dressing rooms in theatres.
CHARLIE
CHAN AT MONTE CARLO:
The brother
who did it—there’s a technical blooper when he runs out into the road and gets “run over” except there
is a glitch in the film. He turns in the road to face the oncoming truck, the
film strip changes to the truck “running over” him.
In the
beginning, when Harold Huber tells CC that HE is going to pay the hotel bill, he takes Chan’s bill, and says “PLEASE!”,
losing his French [sic] accent! (Turn the volume up!). (Courtesy of Norm Vogel).
What
do Black Camel, Monte Carlo, Honolulu,
Shadows Over Chinatown and Shanghai have in common?
Meals at table.
What do
Olympics, Monte Carlo and City in Darkness have in common?
They all have
the same set for the climax of the films.
What
do Shanghai, Monte Carlo, Honolulu
and The Feathered Serpent have in common?
Lee’s
artwork: We see his work in Shanghai, he’s exhibiting one of his works
in Paris in Monte Carlo, Lee is in Art School
in Honolulu and he copies a map in free-hand in The Feathered
Serpent.
What do
Monte Carlo and City in Darkness have in common?
They both have
waste baskets that catch on fire.
What do
Monte Carlo and The Scarlet Clue have in common?
Monte Carlo
has “Waffel!” and Scarlet Clue has Marsh’s Mellow Mix (for waffles).
CHARLIE CHAN IN HONOLULU:
In a
potentially disastrous slip of the mind, Charlie forgot to have a certain bad guy searched for a gun! Fortunately, this criminal didn’t take advantage of Mr. Chan’s apparent slip. Of course, always at least a step (or two!) ahead of all of us, Charlie Chan just MAY have unloaded the
gun earlier at some opportunity unseen by all of us (just as he had another weapon in the same film)! (Courtesy of Rush Glick).
What do
Black Camel, Monte Carlo,
Honolulu and Shanghai have
in common?
Meals at table.
What
do Shanghai, Monte Carlo, Honolulu
and The Feathered Serpent have in common?
Lee’s artwork: We see his work in Shanghai, he’s exhibiting
one of his works in Paris in Monte Carlo, Lee is in Art School
in Honolulu and he copies a map in free-hand in The Feathered
Serpent.
What do
Honolulu, Murder Cruise and The Chinese Ring have in common?
They use freighters
that carry passengers.
What
do Honolulu and Dark Alibi have in common?
Charlie and Jimmy outwit someone who pretends to be deaf (George Zucco in Honolulu
and Milton Parsons in Dark Alibi).
CHARLIE
CHAN IN RENO:
Mary
Whitman and Vivian Welles (Phyllis Brooks) are seated together at a table, and you will notice that the latter is smoking
a cigarette. Pay close attention to the cigarette during this scene, as you will
notice that it goes from just a little stub burnt down to the filter… to a full cigarette, etc….etc. (Courtesy
of Chad Bennett).
Vivian
Wells is wearing a short-sleeved gown the evening of the murder. How does Charlie
know/find out that she wasn’t wearing it’s matching jacket that night?
We never find out what happened to Jimmy’s stolen clothes or his friend’s
car.
What do
London, Paris, Circus, and Reno have in common?
Charlie tells
the investigating officer that if you want a wild bird to sing, do not put him in cage.
CHARLIE
CHAN AT TREASURE ISLAND:
How can
four different actors (Cesear Romero, Gerald Mohr, Sidney Toler and, supposedly, Abdul (The Turk) use the same costume of
Dr. Zodiac without people recognizing their voices?
And how
can Abdul be the good doctor when (1) it would be logistically difficult for him to show them into the séance room and then
show up in full Zodiac costume so quickly and (2) it doesn’t explain Gerald Mohr’s voice out of Zodiac?
This
isn’t a blooper but watch when Chan goes to Zodiac’s house by himself—a black cat runs past him for bad
luck!
The taxi
driver who takes Charlie, Peter Lewis, and Rhadini to Dr. Zodiac’s house doesn’t take the money offered him. He just tears off!
When
our fearless threesome plus Jimmy have broken into Zodiac’s house, they find his blackmailing vault where he keeps file
cabinets of blackmailing information on various people. Charlie starts a fire
with the contents of only a few files out of a few drawers. The others are kept
closed when Chan closes the vault door. Question:
wouldn’t that not only leave most of the files unaffected but severely restrict the oxygen, limiting the potential
for fire damage?
There
is an obvious blooper between when Eve Cairo is levitated and when Jimmy is used. Rhadini
shows that there is nothing under the levitation table when he levitates Eve. The
second time, Rhadini “shows” the underside of the table and there is clearly the wax dummy of Cairo as Jimmy clearly
is thrown from the table through a trap door under the table to the basement.
When
Jimmy slides into the basement during the levitation trick, he rips his pants. So
why doesn’t Eve Cairo get her dresses ripped when she does the trick?
Jimmy
puts on one of Rhadini’s jackets when going on stage to make an announcement for “Pop.” One left shoulder is exaggerated to accommodate Rhadini’s tricks.
What
do Charlie Chan’s Chance, Shanghai, Secret, Treasure Island, Murder Cruise, and Castle in the
Desert have in common?
They
all have cats in them.
What do
Paris, Treasure Island and Murder Cruise have in common?
They have at least two different actors using the same costume and no one can apparently tell them apart by their
voices.
What do
Paris, Shanghai, Treasure Island
and Murder Cruise have in common?
They all have
beggars in them.
What
mode of transportation do the following have in common: Secret, Olympics, Reno, Treasure Island, and Panama?
They all have
characters traveling in clippers.
What do
Treasure Island and Murder Over New York have in common?
Trevor Burdette
plays Hindus in them.
What do
Treasure Island and Wax Museum have in common?
Dr. Zodicac’s
costume .
CHARLIE
CHAN IN ‘CITY IN DARKNESS’:
When
Marcel Spivak goes into the Hotel des Voyageurs, the landlady hurries to close the front door to keep the light from being
seen from the street. However, it looks like what she is actually closing is
the inside door of a lighted vestibule, leaving the outer door in question.
What do
Olympics, Monte Carlo and City in Darkness have in common?
They all have
the same set for the climax of the films.
What do Monte Carlo and City in Darkness have in common?
They both have
wastebaskets that catch on fire.
CHARLIE
CHAN IN PANAMA
At the
beginning, Manolo offers the Englishman Compton a cigarette. He declines, saying he only smokes pipes. Compton
later gets into the cabaret dressing room and lights up a cigarette.
…The
mausoleum owned by the Egyptian tobacconist? They stroll in the front door—fine
so far. It appears to be a small block building—probably room for 8 or
12 bodies. Then Jimmy does his lean-against-the-wall-and-fell-through routine.
But where
does he go?
We find
him in the secret room behind the crypt wall—but where the heck is it? It’s
not 100%below ground. So from the exterior—you’d see a bump-out of
sorts in back? If the Egyptian built this—wouldn’t he have drawn
suspicion? Maybe it’s a double crypt from the outside? We only see the front door. Maybe it’s longer than we
think?
Seemed
like a lot of room behind that fake wall. Somebody would notice. But maybe not. (Courtesy of Jim Mueller).
What do Chance, Broadway, Panama,
and Sky Dragon have in common?
Chance (Charlie), Broadway (LEE), Panama
(Lionel Atwill) and Sky Dragon (Lee and Birmingham Brown)
all broke into ladies’ dressing rooms in theatres.
What do Courage, Panama
and Golden Eye have in common?
Charlie is Ah Kim (A Chinese houseboy)
[sic] in Courage, then Fu Yuen in Panama,
then a jade merchant in The Golden Eye.
What mode of transportation do the following have in common: Secret, Olympics, Reno, Treasure Island, and Panama?
They all have characters traveling in clippers.
What do Race Track, Panama
and the Chan boys have in common?
Charlie recognizes Lee in Race Track and Jimmy in Panama as cabin boys from seeing their backsides and all the
spankings he gave them growing up.
What do Panama, Murder Over
New York, and Murder Over New York
have in common?
A suspect gets shot but no one wants the credit for shooting him.
What do Panama, Rio
and Scarlet Clue have in common?
They involve the use of drugged cigarettes [Courtesy of John Cucinotta].
CHARLIE
CHAN’S MURDER CRUISE:
How can
Leo Carroll and Don Beddoe share the beggar’s costume without thinking that people could tell their voices apart?
You can
tell that Charlie starts the movie with a cold but it seems to fluctuate for the rest of the movie.
Willie’s
arms change position on Charlie’s desk as he gets “into position” for his spanking.
. . . after Inspector Duff is murdered, Charlie, Jimmy and Willy are shown driving
back to the hotel. The beggar approaches Charlie…notice Charlie is NOT
wearing his ring…the camera angle changes…he is now wearing his ring.(Courtesy of Ken D [kend77@msn.com]).
What
do Charlie Chan’s Chance, Shanghai, Secret, Treasure Island, Murder Cruise, and Castle in the
Desert have in common?
They all have cats in them.
What do
Paris, Treasure Island and Murder Cruise have in common?
They have at least two different actors using the same costume and no one can apparently tell them apart by their
voices.
What do
Paris, Shanghai, Treasure Island
and Murder Cruise have in common?
They all have
beggars in them.
What
do Opera, Murder Cruise and Feathered Serpents have in common?
They
all involve weapons that have been wiped clean of fingerprints by someone who may be the bad guy; Opera and Feathered Serpent
used a dagger or knife and Murder Cruise used a gun.
What do
Honolulu, Murder Cruise and The Chinese Ring have in common?
They use freighters
that carry passengers.
What do
Panama, Murder Over New York, and Murder
Over New York have in common?
A suspect gets
shot but no one wants the credit for shooting him.
CHARLIE
CHAN AT THE WAX MUSEUM:
What do
Treasure Island
and Wax Museum have in common?
Dr. Zodicac’s
costume .
MURDER
OVER NEW YORK:
Mountains
appear in the background of the “New York Airport,” which may be the Los Angeles Airport or (more likely) the
Burbank Airport.
The American
Airline plane sits on the tarmac with it’s nose in the air but the passengers inside all sit level, the floor parallel
to the ground.
Why is
there a discrepancy between Charlie’s flight’s scheduled arrival and its actual arrival? (Courtesy of Rush Glick).
Charlie,
Jimmy and Inspector Vance change places by the car on the tarmac after Charlie arrives at the airport.
The fingerprint
man’s pencil knocks over the model plane that’s on the desk. (Courtesy of Rush Glick).
What
are the figures on the wall (or bookcase)? (Courtesy of Rush Glick) .
What do
Chance, Egypt and Murder Over New York
have in common?
They all use
glass containers filled with gas.
What do
Panama, Murder Over New York, and Murder
Over New York have in common?
A suspect gets
shot but no one wants the credit for shooting him.
DEAD
MEN TELL:
Early
in the film, there is a scene with the captain sitting at a desk in an office smoking a pipe.
His pipe keeps changing positions depending on the camera angle, and whether he is going shown up close or through
the window. (Courtesy of John Cucinotta).
. . .
[R]emember when the guys says it was a flying fish………well as
far as I know I have never seen a flying fish in port, only way out at sea. . . . (Courtesy
of Evan Thompson).
The parrot’s
vocalizations don’t match its mouth movements.
CHARLIE
CHAN IN RIO:
What do
Panama,
Rio and Scarlet Clue have in common?
They involve
the use of drugged cigarettes [Courtesy of John Cucinotta].
What do
Rio and Black Magic (Meeting at Midnight) have in common?
They both show
Charlie Chan pretending to be under the influence of drugs.
CASTLE
IN THE DESERT:
In “Castle
in the Desert,” when Charlie first sits down with Mr. Manderley in his study, he attempts to cross his legs and fails
miserably. He continues his dialogue with out missing a beat! (Courtesy of Bill Lutters).
1-A world
famous detective like Charlie must get tons of requests for “Help and advice”..yet, on a note slipped under the
door he changes all his plans without 5 minutes of thought…and heads off to Manderley Castle????
2-Manderley,
a multi-millionaire..has only ONE car?? And a low end one like a Ford..wouldn’t
you think he’d have two..and maybe a Packard or something?
3-Did
Manderley begin his obsession with the Borgias before or after he married his wife?
I, mean..his whole life revolves around the Borgias…his car has the Borgia crest, he built a castle like the
one Caesre Borgia had..and he tells Lucy..we won’t discuss it????
4-The
scar…the owner of the hotel tells Charlie “He won’t talk civil to nobody”…so I’m expected
to believe he cares what he townspeople gossip about him?” The scarf probably
would make it worse.
5-When
Lucy calls Watson King “Jim”…what was all that about?
6-When
Charlie shows the Dr. the bottle with the tagara weed, and the Doctor tells Charlie his knowledge of the drug…yet, in
the scene in Lucy’s room the Dr. tells Charlie “Where did we obtain the drug, it’s very rare?’’…maybe
out of the bottle Charlie showed you a couple of scenes back!
7-At
the end of the film Lucy says she is left-handed…yet, if you watch her throughout the film…she does everything
right-hand.
8-If
Watson King is really a world famous sculptor…and the step-brother of Lucy…why would he need to try and tap into
the lawyer for a touch? (Robert J. Hiza).
#6 In
regards to “Jim”, It appears from a GOOGLE Search that in 1930’s slang
“Jim” is roughly equivalent to “Buddy” or “Mac”.
A more modern example would be from the song “Werewolves of London”
“….Better
stay away from him
Hell
rip your lungs out, Jim…..” (Courtesy of Julian M. Lobacewski).
As you
point out, this film has a lot of plot loopholes, as well as other things that make me wonder:
1. The castle has a lot of servants and guards. Do they live there, or do they commute
from somewhere, like the Mojave Wells town, and would they need another car to do so?
2. Even with no running water or laundry facilities, the inhabitants of the castle look
very well groomed.
3. Apparently an elegant meal is being planned for the guests. It would have to be cooked in a primitive wood stove, or over a fire.
How can you store food in such a castle with no refrigeration. (Courtesy of John Cucinotta).
I was just
wondering (here we go with the hat thing again), did anyone notice in “Castle in the Desert: that when Honorable Chan
step from the taxi that brought him to the towns [sic] only hotel, that when
he steped [sic] from the taxi his white hat was creased or “dented” in the back of his hat and in the next scene,
seemingly by magic the dent was gone. Hollywood magic I guess, sort of like the
gus that seem not to run out of bullits, [sic] etc. (Courtesy of Ken Miller,
kmillerqw@hot.rr.com, October 6, 2004).
What
do Charlie Chan’s Chance, Shanghai, Secret, Treasure Island, Murder Cruise, and Castle in the
Desert have in common?
They
all have cats in them.
SECRET
SERVICE:
When
the inventor blows up the ships in his lab at the beginning of the movie, the background doesn’t match the mid-shot.
What
about the bomb…all were dummies…so how did they explode when he threw one, if he had trown the loaded one they
would all be dead…why? Because if you remember the inventor said if that
one was to go off it would blow everything within 2 blocks to bits…so what explodes?
that chans son threw ??? (Courtesy
of Evan Thompson).
Charlie
walks through the deserted lobby of a federal building in Washington, D.C., and onto almost as deserted street with little
foot and no vehicular traffic to a taxi that just “happens” to be at curbside.
The California
State Flag flying in front of a government building in Washington [D.C.], as well as Charlie’s long walk from the taxi
to the house. Daytime when he starts and night when he arrives. (Courtesy of Bill Lutters).
Charlie’s
kids, Tommy and Iris, are in his office when he comes in and announces that he has to leave them for a murder investigation. Iris says they don’t know where he’s going and Tommy announces he knows
how to figure out where “Pop” is going. The next scene finds them
at the right house.
When
did anyone have the opportunity to electrify the closet door and do the remote switch or the magnetized gun set-up
Now if
you have ever seen (he Boogie man will get you)with [sic] boris and peter lorre you will see Mantan in the same machine only
in the Charlie Chan one…Mantan jumps in it just before the shooting starts, and comes out and asks them what’s
going on I thought I heard shots fired. (Courtesy of Evan Thompson).
Note
when Charlie is shot at from behind a curtain, looks like Mantan walks out from behind the same curtain or very close to it. (Courtesy of Evan Thompson).
The spy
lady made a Statue of Liberty for the inventer before she got to his house, so how did the secret plans get inside of it ??? Charlie had to break it to find the plans..not dig into the bottom, if it was closed
off..? (Courtesy of Evan Thompson).
and how
did she know that her partner in crime was going to sit in the couch right under the gun??
(Courtesy of Evan Thompson).
…[W]hen
in the inventors work shop they are shot at by someone..Benson Fong throws a “bomb that is supposed to be a dummy, yet
it explodes, had or if he trew the one with the+ on it they as the inventor said ..they would have been blown to bits for
2 blocks around…yet the explosion didn’t do much more than a fire cracker… oh by the way in slang on your
blog..a joint is also a marijuana “stick” smoke looks like a roll your own cigarette…just thought I’d
drop that on youheheheheee…I think theres another blooper or 2 in that movie…note when Charlie is shot at frm
behind a curtain, looks like Mantan walks out from behind the same curtain or very close to it…chk it out. I like that movie…and hey…how about this one
the spy lady made a Statue of Liberty for the inventor before she got to his house, so how did the secret plans get
inside of it???Charlie had to break it to find the plans,,not dig into the bottom, if it was closed off..? and how did she know that her partner in crime was going to sit in the couch right under the gun??there
are a few questions more but that will give you something to hehehe ”Chew” on for a while ….yer pal Evan
the blooper snooper…….heheheheeeee
What do Secret Service and Shanghai
Cobra have in common?
They both have the Federal Building scene that’s supposed to be set in Washington,
D.C., during World War II, yet there are few people and fewer cars. On top of
that, the California State Flag is flying
at full staff in front of the Federal Building.
CHINESE
CAT:
My favourite
is in Chinese Cat where the character [sic] Webster Deacon (Cy Kendall) is murdered and the newspaper headline reads that
“George Deacon” died. (Courtesy of Chris Ellis).
[D]id
anybody ever respond to the message about Mantan turning the knob on the radio to the left to turn on the music in the car? He turned to the right to turn it off. . .also later they had the whipers [sic] going
without any rain….just curious…watched it last night it actually is one of the best IMHO…. (Courtesy of orzobino).
BLACK
MAGIC/MEETING AT MIDNIGHT:
Charlie
“making” the skeleton go back into the wall. His hand remains closed
like he’s just running it back and forth instead of the repeated grasping motion needed to actually move any kind of
wire forward.
. . .
when Charlie is in the police department explaining how he is psychic, and the handkerchief dances above his head, take a
close look behind him and you can see the lever going up and down that the prop man is using to make the handkerchief jump. That’s as bad a blooper as the scrim in front of the lamp in Dracula. . . . (Courtesy of Robert S.).
The killer’s
voice calls to Justine from a partially opened door when she is on the roof of a tall office building, luring her forward,
resulting in her falling off the roof to her death. A few seconds later the killer
is seen at street level on the sidewalk.
What do
Rio and
Black Magic (Meeting at Midnight) have in common?
They both show
Charlie Chan pretending to be under the influence of drugs.
JADE
MASK:
The front door has only a handle on the inside . . . no handle on the outside and certainly no keyhole anywhere!
The “Human Puppet” is animated from the second floor but . . .
either it’s a trap door under a rug that they have to move or else it has some kind of handle to pull up. Why doesn’t anybody notice this stuff in the movie?!
SCARLET
CLUE:
Birmingham
Brown’s screams don’t match the way his mouth moves in The Scarlet Clue when he’s caught in the Hamilton
Lab between the lightning “lamps.”
What do
Panama,
Rio and Scarlet Clue have in common?
They involve
the use of drugged cigarettes [Courtesy of John Cucinotta].
SHANGHAI
COBA:
The scene
in Secret Service where Charlie leaves the Federal Building in Washington with the California Flag flying in front. (Courtesy of John Cucinotta).
Charlie
was in Shanghai eight years before about arresting Jan Van Horn who escaped from the police boat~~The police hadn’t
sat him down so it was easy for him to escape by distracting one and pushing the other off balance and then he jumped out
and swam off. With his hands still in handcuffs?
And we
aren’t supposed to match Jan Van Horn’s voice with [(Addison Richards’) later character]?
What
do Shanghai
Cobra and Dark Alibi have in common?
They both have
early scenes involving big safety deposit vaults in banks.
What do Secret Service and Shanghai
Cobra have in common?
They
both have the Federal Building scene that’s supposed to be set in Washington, D.C., during World War II, yet there are
few people and fewer cars. On top of that, the California
State Flag is flying at full staff in front of the Federal Building.
RED DRAGON:
When
CC is explaining about the “95th Element” to the inspector, he starts to get confused, as if he’s
desperately trying to remember his lines! (I’m surprised that they didn’t
reshoot that scene, unless it was made by “One Shot” Beaudine!). (Courtesy
of Norm Vogel).
Also,
no one can figure out what the typed word was, but once it’s solved, EVRYONE seems to remember where the thermostat
was & wasn’t! I mean, WHO notices something like THAT?!?!?! (Courtesy
of Norm Vogel).
AND….as
he was typing it (as he was dying, he only hit about 3 or 4 keystrokes, but the word has over TWICE that many! Go figure! (Courtesy of Norm Vogel).
Lastly,
I find it “odd” that CC would PUSH the button on the t-stat: If anyone
ELSE had on of those gizmos on them, he would have KILLED THEM, TOO! Strange! (Courtesy of Norm Vogel).
DARK
ALIBI:
Charlie
calls one of the female suspects by the wrong name in an early scene in the lobby of the rooming house. (Courtesy of John Cucinotta).
What do Shanghai Cobra and Dark Alibi have in common?
They both have early scenes involving big safety deposit vaults in banks.
What do Dark Alibi, Shanghai
Chest, The Golden Eye, and Sky Dragon have in common?
In Dark Alibi, Tim Ryan was “Froggie;” in Shanghai
Chest, he’s listed under additional dialogue; and in the casts of Shanghai
Chest, The Golden Eye, and Sky Dragon as Lt. Mike Ruark.
SHADOWS OVER CHINATOWN:
The back
window on the bus had a vertical bar in it when the bus turned into the bus station that the window didn’t have when
Charlie was talking to the two little old ladies.
[Charlie]
runs into an elderly lady whose grand daughter is missing, he goes to the missing persons office and finds a photo of her
missing, goes to the grandmother and talks a while, then at a café he spots her…and produces a photo of her…and
shows it to son Tommy…where did he get that picture of her? He didn’t
ask granny for one and the missing persons place didn’t have one…I watched it 3 times, and I never seen him procure
one anywhere in the movie…just a little fun like the turtle with the flash lite on its back, (Courtesy of Evan Thompson).
[I had
posted a “whazit” (as opposed to a blooper) on the CCMB about where the turtle with the flashlight on it’s
back came from.] …just a little fun like the turtle with the flash lite on its back, I do know the flashlite was Willy
Bests as he dropped his when scared, how it balanced on the turtles back is another quirk, but fun… (Courtesy of Evan Thompson).
The morgue
doesn’t have a knob on the inside of the door?!
What
do Black Camel, Monte Carlo, Honolulu,
Shadows Over Chinatown, and Shanghai Chest have in common?
Meals at table.
What do
Olympics and Shadow Over Chinatown have in common?
They both use
sign language.
What
do Panama, Murder Over New York, and Murder
Over New York have in common?
A suspect gets
shot but no one wants the credit for shooting him.
DANGEROUS
MONEY:
My wife
and I were watching Dangerous money last nite and I noticed some similarity in the music at the start of it and the start
of The Jade Mask…and one other of the CC films but can’t remember which…maybe I’m just getting crazier….and
she noticed that when Willy Best dropped in on the cook, he burned his fanny, BUT? When he got down he touched the edge of
that same grill and didn’t get burnt…we slow motioned it several times and it sure looked like he did touch the
same hot area only at the edge…now we had one of those resturant sized grils in our home for many years and I have grated
(holy stone, Cleaned) them many times and where he touched is very hot…10 kids we needed that grill…its been since
donated to our local Lions club…and the knife seen in the door way was drawn back a if it were being thrown…but
yet we are told its being shot, am I right or didn’t I hear a reason because I fell asleep before I fell asleep before
the end….ZZzzz Evan(Courtesy of Evan Thompson).
Freddie,
the knife thrower, is running away from the museum. A knife gets him. You hear the sound of a woman laughing in the distance….which sounds rather (for want of a better
word) “surrealistic” to laff at someone’s death…..but CC doesn’t want to investigate……he
(rightly) feels that it’s just 2 lovers in the jungle….. (Courtesy
of Norm Vogel).
TRAP:
Someone
is supposed to run across the beach behind the opening credits. (Courtesy of
Rush Glick).
When
King Cole and his troop arrive at the Malibu house and they start piling out of the station wagon . . . just how many people
are IN that station wagon?
The phone
call to Birmingham gives the address of the beach house in Malibu, but a close up of the front door shows a different address
later.
This
same phone call that gives Birmingham the address. . . . He scribbles what looks
like two letters or numbers but Jimmy can read the entire address when he shows up looking for Birmingham.
The house
is architecturally off. At least one front bedroom has a window in the common
wall with the room behind it.
When
it’s revealed that the doctor is married to one of the showgirls (who’s supposed to be French), she gets emotional
and hugs the doctor, losing her French accent and says “What’s the difference?” where she SHOULD have said,
“What’s za dif-far-ANCE!”. (Courtesy of Norm Vogel).
One of
the beach scenes has the beach ball tossed one way and it’s seen going in another direction in the next shot. (Courtesy of Doug Palmer).
Charlie
not only doesn’t seem to care that the villain steals his car but wrecks it as well at the end of the movie. (Courtesy of Doug Palmer).
CHINESE
RING:
What do Honolulu, Murder Cruise and The Chinese Ring have in common?
They use freighters that carry passengers.
What do The Chinese Ring and Docks of New Orleans
have in common?
They were both made from James Lee Wong stories—The Chinese Ring
from Mr. Wong in Chinatown and Docks of New Orleans from Mr.
Wong, Detective.
What do The Chinese Ring and Docks of New Orleans
have in common?
They both use the same dock and ship scene.
DOCKS
OF NEW ORLEANS:
Tommy
and Birmingham’s playing “Chop Suey Boogie” don’t match the sound.
What do
The Chinese Ring and Docks of New Orleans have in common?
They were both made from James Lee Wong stories—The Chinese Ring from Mr. Wong in Chinatown and Docks of New Orleans from Mr. Wong, Detective.
What do
The Chinese Ring and Docks of New Orleans have in common?
They both use
the same dock and ship scene.
SHANGHAI
CHEST:
Willie
Best (playing Willie Best) . . . his hands change position on the cell door, depending on the camera angle.
Charlie
experiments with making fingerprints with Birmingham, forgetting what he and the police learned in Dark Alibi.
If Birmingham
overslept, then who fixed Charlie and Tommy’s breakfast?
What do
Black Camel, Monte Carlo,
Honolulu and Shanghai have
in common?
Meals at table.
What
do Dark Alibi, Shanghai Chest, The Golden Eye, and Sky Dragon
Have in common?
In
Dark Alibi, Tim Ryan was “Froggie;” in Shanghai Chest, he’s listed under
additional dialogue; and in the casts of Shanghai Chest, The
Golden Eye, and Sky Dragon as Lt. Mike Ruark.
What
do Dark Alibi and Shanghai Chest have in common?
In Dark Alibi Sidney Toler used faked fingerprints as did Roland Winters in Shanghai
Chest.
MYSTERY
OF THE GOLDEN EYE:
W hat do
Courage, Panama and Golden Eye have in common?
Charlie is Ah Kim (A Chinese houseboy) [sic] in Courage, then Fu Yuen
in Panama, then a jade merchant in The Golden Eye.
What
do Dark Alibi, Shanghai Chest, The Golden Eye, and Sky Dragon
Have in common?
In
Dark Alibi, Tim Ryan was “Froggie;” in Shanghai Chest, he’s listed under
additional dialogue; and in the casts of Shanghai Chest, The
Golden Eye, and Sky Dragon as Lt. Mike Ruark.
FEATHERED
SERPENT:
If you
look carefully enough, you’ll see the block of wood that Professor Stanley had between his back and shirt that held
the knife that he was “stabbed” with.
Did Lee
and Tommy have their camping clothes with them (or where else did they get them on short notice)? If they brought them with them then why didn’t Charlie and Birmingham bring them to wear them? Or was Birmingham’s job to stay in his chauffeur’s uniform?
When
Birmingham is helping Pedro with the dishes in camp, he looks like he might be quitting twice on the job.
What
do Shanghai,
Monte Carlo, Honolulu and The
Feathered Serpent have in common?
Lee’s artwork: We see his work in Shanghai, he’s exhibiting
one of his works in Paris in Monte Carlo, Lee is in Art School
in Honolulu and he copies a map in free-hand in The Feathered
Serpent.
What
do Opera, Murder Cruise and Feathered Serpents have in common?
They
all involve weapons that have been wiped clean of fingerprints by someone who may be the bad guy; Opera and Feathered Serpent used a dagger or knife and Murder Cruise used a gun.
SKY DRAGON:
What do
Chance, Broadway,
Panama, and Sky Dragon have in common?
Chance (Charlie), Broadway (Lee), Panama (Lionel Atwill) and Sky
Dragon (Lee and Birmingham Brown) all broke into ladies’
dressing rooms in theatres.
What do
Chance, Egypt and Murder Over New York have in common?
They all use
glass spheres filled with gas.
What
do Dark Alibi, Shanghai Chest, The Golden Eye, and Sky Dragon
Have in common?
In
Dark Alibi, Tim Ryan was “Froggie;” in Shanghai Chest, he’s listed under
additional dialogue; and in the casts of Shanghai Chest, The
Golden Eye, and Sky Dragon as Lt. Mike Ruark.
THE NEW ADVENTRUES OF CHARLIE CHAN:
J. Carroll Naish not only
appeared in Circus, he was the main bad guy, Naish went on to be the only actor
(and bad guy!) to go on and play the Chinese detective, on English television in a half-hour
drama in the 1950’s.
*This page, like most on this website, is a work in progress
so please let Maven know if you have any additions, comments, questions or suggestions at theoldmoviemaven@yahoo.com.
|